Zhou Yu’s Train

The more I hate this movie, the more I can find things in it that I like.

The narrative is all twisted. A girl falls for a poet and this is the main thread of the story. Around this we have a veterinirian who falls for her and another girl who also falls for the poet, but from a distance.

So let’s try to tie it all up. A girl falls for a poet who writes poems about her. She travels a long distance by train very often to go see him. They make passionate love. During these train travels she meets a veterinian who falls for her, she has an affair with him while the poet is in Tibet on a teaching assignment. Later on, the girl dies in a tragic bus accident. But there is another girl as well, an anonymous girl seen throughout the movie reading a book of poetry, supposedly a book from our poet.

The poet’s relationship with Zhou Yu (our main protoganist) mirrors her relationship with the veterinirian. This mirroring is interesting, but far too simple. In the poet relationship, she plays the wounded. In the vet relationship, she plays the wounder, but only at the end. Our anonymous reader later serves as a stand-in for the gone Zhou Yu. Our poet is troubled by this. Shame, loss, a poet’s life.

There are some very beautiful images of trains and rural landscapes. There are very beautiful skies as well. The camera is calm and serene for the most part. The mixing and editing is inspired by Kar-Wai Wong, fortunately less obvious than Purple Butterfly.

“A lover is a mirror through which one can see themselves clearly.” I know nothing of Northern China, and long and baggy flowery dresses are not appealing to me. Neither is undone wavy hair (Kar-Wai made her look much more beautiful). I believe this is cultural. I loved the ideas in this film, but the people, the emotions, and the acting, were not beautiful enough.

See this if you can tolerate the aesthetic choices.

Advertisements

Categories: Notes

1 reply »

  1. What if you look at it like this….each person in the film is dreaming their own dream and others are characters in their “dream” or perceived reality. Yes, all are mirrors. This movie to me explores the idea of the search for the ‘soul-mate’, the one who can mirror and reveal us to ourselves, but the characters find that this is only partially possible, different aspects of ourselves are mirrored by different people, thus loss and frustration, when someone doesn’t “fit our dream”. The poet wonders if Zhou Yu loves him for himself or for his poetry. He is identified with the poet in himself so ends up with the “fan” of his poetry, does he even dimly acknowledge “using” Zhou Yu as his muse when he hears of her death and denies (shuts out the reality he doesn’t wish to accept) that she was with another man? Zhou Yu has to ‘follow her heart’ to her death. The vet has discovered his heart through suffering but will probably get on with life….as sting has said “how fragile we are”, it all amounts to just a lot of broken chinese vases….

    I agree with you about the floral numbers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s